decisiondecided

Protect user privacy by default

Context

  • Authentication method and the scope of personal information collection are decisions that are costly to change later
  • Parlourite is a casual board game site with little intrinsic need to hold personal information
  • Looking ahead to AI research use and public replay sharing, operating without personally identifying information is safer
  • At the same time, without authentication, continuity of match history, settings, and rankings cannot be guaranteed

Options

Baseline: email + password. Evaluation criteria:

  • C1: User privacy / C2: Security (resistance to account takeover)
  • C3: UX (registration and login friction) / C4: Recoverability (loss scenarios)
  • C5: Legal compliance cost (GDPR / Japan’s Act on Protection of Personal Information) / C6: Implementation and operational cost
OptionC1C2C3C4C5C6Total
Email + password (Baseline)0000000
Email + magic link0+++00+3
OAuth (Google / Apple etc.)—+++-++1
Passkey only + no personally identifying information+++++-++0+6

Decision

Use Passkey (FIDO2 / WebAuthn) as the sole authentication method, and collect no personally identifying information such as name, email address, or phone number.

  • Account creation is completed by Passkey registration alone
  • Recovery codes are self-managed by the user
  • Non-recoverable loss scenarios are accepted as a tradeoff and clearly stated in the Terms of Service
  • Only a user-chosen display name is used for rankings, replays, and similar surfaces

Rationale

  • Holding no personally identifying information contributes simultaneously to privacy protection, breach-risk reduction, and lower compliance cost
  • Passkey offers strong phishing resistance and improves security compared to password-based operation
  • Consistent with the two-click play policy (2026-10-18-two-click-play): the model of “sign up lightly only when it becomes necessary” holds
  • Non-recoverability is an acceptable tradeoff given the nature of a game-play site (unlike financial or medical services)

Consequences

  • Positive: Minimized impact of any potential breach, reduced GDPR / APPI exposure, compatibility with future replay publishing and research use
  • Negative: No recovery path on Passkey loss, inconvenience for users on environments without Passkey support
  • Follow-up: Continued monitoring of browser / OS coverage; recovery UX improvements to be examined in a separate ADR